Malverne Pastry Shop

Nestled in the heart of Malverne, NY, Malverne Pastry Shop stands as a beloved local bakery that truly delights the senses with every visit. Located at 253 Hempstead Ave, this charming pastry haven offers an exquisite range of handcrafted treats, each made with passion and undeniable quality. Whether you’re hunting for a show-stopping wedding cake, a delicate mini fruit tart, or a nostalgic slice of strawberry shortcake, Malverne Pastry Shop promises a delightful experience that keeps customers coming back time and again.

What sets Malverne Pastry Shop apart is its masterful menu selection, which features favorites like the irresistibly light and creamy Strawberry Shortcake, the elegantly layered Napoleon Cake, and the rich, velvety Carrot Cake Muffins. Fans rave about their Vanilla Bourbon Mini Cake, which marries subtle warmth with sweetness, and the Pignoli Cookies, perfectly crisp with a nutty finish. Cookies, tarts, and specialty birthday cakes are crafted with equal care, each bite bursting with fresh, authentic flavors that speak to the bakery’s commitment to quality.

Malverne Pastry Shop's reputation is not just about their delectable pastries, but also the attentive and thoughtful service that accompanies every visit. Customers frequently praise the staff's kindness and professionalism. Enza shares, "You could never go wrong at Malverne Pastry Shop. Delicious cakes, cookies, and pastries. My go-to place all the time. Everything is always fresh and tasty. Staff is always courteous, professional and so very kind. Such a great place." This heartfelt endorsement captures the genuine warmth that permeates this bakery.

William Jacobs highlights their customer-first mindset, noting how the team went above and beyond even when closing time was imminent: "If you're looking for a sweet treat that is both delicious and accompanied by great customer service, then Malverne Pastry Shop is definitely the place to go." Such dedication reflects their goal to make every visit memorable, no matter how busy or close to closing.

While the bakery receives universal acclaim, it’s refreshing to see honest feedback like that from Dawn Windheuser, who cherishes their strawberry shortcake but gently suggests that packaging could be improved to protect the delicate creations. This kind of openness only reinforces the bakery’s willingness to listen and evolve.

What truly strikes you upon stepping into Malverne Pastry Shop is the care put into both product and experience. From the homemade cannoli cream layer cake to the classic apple tart, each item invites you to savor a moment of joy. The bakery’s passion shines through the freshness of their fruit-topped cheesecakes and the expertly balanced flavors of their raspberry cream cake.

Fariha M Rehan beautifully summarizes the magic here: "This cutest little bakery has the most delicious and mouth-watering baked items! The staff is so kind, friendly and helpful and offer great suggestions. My daughter’s birthday cake was delicious and very fresh. Highly recommend!" And for those who travel far just to indulge, Daniella Pellicane’s words ring with loyalty: "The cakes are delicious. Every occasion we make sure to come here for all our cakes and desserts! And the people who work here are so nice! I recommend this bakery to everyone! I live 40 minutes away and this is the only bakery I use! Nothing compares!"

Whether you need a comforting treat to brighten your afternoon or an elegant centerpiece for a special event, Malverne Pastry Shop delivers quality, freshness, and heartfelt service that turns moments into memories. For a truly sweet experience in Malverne, this bakery is a destination you won’t want to miss.

Location: 253 Hempstead Ave, Malverne, NY 11565
Phone: +1 516-599-3087